Comelec defends decision vs Padaca
The Commission on Elections has defended its decision to unseat Grace Padaca as governor of Isabela, saying the ruling has nothing to do with the reported âpolitical vendetta" of the Arroyo administration against its opponents. âWe rule on the basis of merit⦠Malacañang does not intervene, " Commissioner Lucenito Tagle told GMANews.TV on Wednesday, speaking on behalf of the Comelec Second Division that ruled on Padacaâs case. On December 8, the poll body declared as null and void the term of Padaca in favor of former governor Bejamin Dy, who contested the results of the 2007 elections. Comelec records show that the Provincial Board of Canvassers of Isabela proclaimed Padaca as the governor of the province after receiving 237,128 votes in the 2007 polls versus Dyâs 220,121 votes â a winning margin of 17,007. Dy, however, challenged the results in 13 towns namely Cordon, Echague, San Agustin, San Isidro, Delfin Albano, Tumauini, Ilagan, Luna, San Guillermo, Mallig, Quezon, Jones, and Ramon. Padaca, for her part, also contested the results in the towns of Alicia, Angadanan, Aurora, Gamu, Ilagan, Luna, Reina Mercedes, San Guillermo, San Mariano, and Cauayan City. Appreciation of ballots The Comelec ruled that the final appreciation of the contested ballots show that Dy is the rightful Isabela governor with 199,435 votes as compared to Padacaâs 198,384 votes â a margin of 1,051 votes. On Tuesday, Dy said that thousands of ballots with the same handwritings in favor of Padaca were found in several contested precincts, thereby depriving him of the governorship. Comelec spokesman James Jimenez told GMANews.TV on Wednesday that there were in fact some ballots that had the same handwriting on them, though he couldnât indicate how many. âWe go by the results of the appreciation. They had the opportunity to contest each and every ballot," said Jimenez. 12,000-page resolution The âappreciation" of ballots, however, was questioned by several critics, including Padaca who said that the 12,000-page resolution made it harder for her camp to know which part to contest. Jimenez, however, said that there was nothing suspicious about the resolution. âWe believe the decision itself, it was very well-documented," he said. Tagle also said there was nothing âirregular" with having more than 12,000 pages in a single resolution. âSupreme Court requires us to explain, depende sa (it depends on the) protested ballots," he said, adding that the more contested ballots, the thicker a resolution would be. - KIMBERLY JANE T. TAN, GMANews.TV Many thought that her 2007 victory as a second-term governor was also the extension of the peopleâs victory against a three-decade dynastic rule in Isabela province. But on December 8, Grace Padaca â the only Filipino local official honored last year with a Ramon Magsaysay award for supposedly empowering voters to reclaim their democratic right - was unseated from her post through a 12,000-page decision by the Commission on Elections (Comelec). Shock was Padacaâs initial reaction to the Comelecâs decision. â
Di ko maubos maisip na âyung 17,000 votes
na lamang ko sa kanya na ganun na lang mababaligtad. (I canât imagine how my 17,000-vote lead over him would be turned around just like that)." Padaca was referring to Benjamin Dy, her political opponent who, according to the âfinal appreciation" of the Comelecâs Second Division, won the 2007 polls with 198,384 votes or a winning margin of 1,051 votes over that of Padaca. According to Padaca, Dyâs petition failed to substantiate how he regained the 17,000 votes from her, unlike her evidence of 46 pages, including folders of the photocopies of ballots detailing how she maintained the 17,000-vote lead. After the disbelief came Padacaâs realization that the issue was no longer about her, but the peopleâs trust in the Comelec's capability to ensure clean and honest elections in 2010. â
Hindi ako kapit-tuko sa kapangyarihan. I just want to be assured
na di ako ginagago sa prosesong ito. This is not just about me.
Paano pa mapagkakatiwalaan ang Comelec sa 2010 election? (Iâm not clinging to power. I just want to be assured that Iâm not being fooled in this process. How can the Comelec be trusted in the 2010 polls?)" said Padaca. At least one political analyst shares Padacaâs view. Ramon Casiple, executive director of the Institute for Political and Electoral Reform, sees an âalarming" pattern not just in the recent decisions of the Comelec, but also in the rulings of Supreme Court that could have a ânegative bearing on the conduct of fair and honest elections" next year. [See:
SC: Appointive officials may hold on to posts after filing COCs and
SC: Infomercials before campaign period legal] â
Ang tanong kasi ay kung mananalo ba ang administrasyon sa susunod na eleksyon? (The question is will the administration win in the coming elections?)⦠So what is the administration up to now?" said Casiple in an interview with GMANews.TV on Wednesday. "It is placing its people in the government a few months before the polls so they can access government resources for the campaign and ensure the victory of the administration in rich-vote areas," added Casiple. Casiple said the situation being faced by Padaca is similar to that of Jonjon Mendoza who was earlier unseated by the same Comelec division headed by commissioner Nicodemo Ferrer after the Bulacan governor decided to leave the administration party in favor of the Liberal Party. Last September, Padaca and Pampanga governor Ed Panlilio also decided to throw their support behind LP standard-bearer, Sen. Benigno Simeon âNoynoy" Aquino III. Like Padaca and Mendoza, administration allies are also trying to unseat Panlilio from his gubernatorial post. In the 2007 polls, Panlilio beat Lilia Pineda by 1,407 votes, a margin repeatedly challenged by his political opponents until the election case was elevated to the Supreme Court. The high tribunal recently decided to resume the hearing of the petition questioning Panlilioâs victory. But Casiple said the tight situation being faced by progressive leaders such as Padaca âwill just be temporary." â
Malaki ang possibility
na manalo uli si Padaca
at iba pang progressive leaders (Thereâs a big possibility that Padaca and other progressive leaders will win again in the 2007 polls). In the light of the Noynoy phenomenon, I think 40 to 50 percent of the electorate will vote based on issues and not on personalities," said Casiple.
- with reports from Kimberly Jane T. Tan, GMANews.TV